Ethiopia crash captain did not train on airline’s MAX simulator: source

ADDIS ABABA:  The captain of a doomed Ethiopian Airways flight didn’t get an opportunity to observe on his airline’s new simulator for the Boeing 737 MAX eight earlier than he died in a crash with 157 others, a pilot colleague stated.

Captain Yared Getachew, 29, was due for refresher coaching on the finish of March, his colleague advised Reuters, two months after Ethiopian Airways had acquired one of many first such simulators being distributed.

The March 10 catastrophe, following one other MAX eight crash in Indonesia in October, has set off one of many largest inquiries in aviation historical past, centered on the protection of a brand new automated system and whether or not crews understood it correctly.

In each circumstances, the pilots misplaced management quickly after take-off and fought a dropping battle to cease their jets plunging down.

The MAX, which got here into service two years in the past, has a brand new automated system referred to as MCAS (Maneuvering Traits Augmentation System). It’s meant to forestall lack of carry which might trigger an aerodynamic stall sending the aircraft downwards in an uncontrolled approach.

 “Boeing didn’t ship manuals on MCAS,” the Ethiopian Airways pilot advised Reuters in a resort foyer, declining to offer his title as employees have been advised to not converse in public.

 “Truly we all know extra in regards to the MCAS system from the media than from Boeing.”

Below unprecedented scrutiny and with its MAX fleet grounded worldwide, the world’s largest planemaker has stated airways got steerage on how to answer the activation of MCAS software program. It’s also promising a swift replace.

Boeing didn’t instantly reply to a request for touch upon the pilot’s remarks. It has not stated 737 pilots ought to prepare on one of many new simulators to fly a 737 MAX, which has bigger engines mounted barely extra ahead than the earlier mannequin.

Learn Extra: Ethiopian crash crew’s voices could unlock high-stakes Boeing inquiry

 “I believe that the variations between the 737 NG and the MAX have been underplayed by Boeing,” stated John Cox, an aviation security advisor, former U.S. Airways pilot and former air security chairman of the U.S. Airline Pilots Affiliation.

 “Consequently the simulator producers weren’t pushing it both. The operators didn’t understand the magnitude of the variations,” he advised Reuters in a communication over the Ethiopian pilot’s remarks.


Ethiopian Airways stated on Thursday its pilots had accomplished coaching beneficial by Boeing and accepted by the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) on variations between the earlier 737 NG plane and the 737 MAX model.

They have been additionally briefed on an emergency directive after the Indonesia crash, which was integrated into manuals and procedures, it stated in a tweet. The 737 MAX simulator was not designed to copy the MCAS system issues, it added.

 “We urge all involved to chorus from making such uninformed, incorrect, irresponsible and deceptive statements throughout the interval of the accident investigation,” it stated.

Yared’s brother stated he traveled to Miami twice within the final two years to coach on a simulator there, however he didn’t know which one. Miami has had a 737 MAX simulator since 2017.

Globally, most industrial airline pilots refresh coaching in simulators each six months. Within the Ethiopian crash, it was not clear if Yared’s colleague – First Officer Ahmednur Mohammed, 25, who additionally died within the crash – had used the brand new simulator.

The 737 MAX eight was launched into industrial service in 2017, however pilots of older 737s have been solely required to have computer-based coaching to change, in accordance with Boeing, airways, unions and regulators.

By December, two months after the Lion Air crash that killed 189 folks off Jakarta, the primary simulator producer CAE Inc of Canada stated it had delivered simply 4 MAX simulators to airways.

At the moment, CAE had orders from airways globally for 30 MAX simulators, which value between $6 million and $15 million every relying on customization.

The world’s largest 737 operator, Southwest Airways Co, is not going to have its first MAX simulator prepared to be used till October, its pilot union stated on Wednesday.

“It’s nonetheless very disturbing to us that Boeing didn’t disclose MCAS to the operators and pilots,” the affiliation advised members in a memo seen by Reuters.



Leave a Reply

Back to top button