Kyler Murray decision: Debating the pros and cons of the NFL vs. MLB | NFL

Kyler Murray is a particular expertise.  

He won the Heisman Trophy because the quarterback for the Oklahoma Sooners in 2018 in his first 12 months as a full-time starter. He additionally was chosen with the No. 9 choose within the 2018 MLB Draft by the Oakland Athletics, a contract that comes with a $4.66 million signing bonus.  

Murray performed soccer as a junior and has two attainable profession choices. He can report back to spring coaching in February, or he can go to the NFL Draft, select soccer as an alternative and pay again his signing bonus. 

The San Francisco Chronicle reported Wednesday night that the A’s count on Murrary to enter the NFL Draft, and that the announcement will come Sunday. However till Murray makes his selection public, there stays an air of secrecy over the choice.

However is soccer the appropriate resolution for Murray? Is baseball? Might he do each? SN’s Ryan Fagan and Invoice Bender focus on.  

MORE: Spring training reporting dates for all 30 MLB teams

Fagan: Kyler ought to completely play baseball. He is been drafted into a company that enthusiastically believes in his future, in his potential to be a star on and off the sector. A’s entrance workplace guru Billy Beane was named the 2018 Sporting Information Govt of the 12 months — the third time he is received in his groundbreaking profession — and once I offered him the award on the Winter Conferences in December, I requested him about Murray. His face lit up.  

“I feel the complete nation can see why we might take him with the ninth choose,” Beane advised me, together with his Hollywood grin at peak ranges. “As thrilling as he’s on the soccer area, a few of these ability units translate to baseball, and that is why getting him on the baseball area — not only for the A’s, however for baseball on the whole — might be nice for the sport.” 

The A’s consider in Murray. Groups do not waste first-round picks on gamers they do not consider in. As a baseball participant, Murray is a uncooked expertise, certain. However the A’s will spend money on giving him the instruments — and the time — to succeed in the heights of his expertise. Murray is aware of this, with out a shadow of a doubt. Will he get the identical remedy if he dives into the NFL Draft? Who is aware of? Certain, Murray is a sizzling prospect now, however there’s a very long time between now and the draft. What occurs if his inventory slides and he winds up as a third- or fourth-round choose? It is onerous to think about a soccer workforce believing in him as wholly because the A’s do. A number of unknowns with the soccer route.  

Bender: There are simply as many unknowns in baseball, and judging from Murray’s feedback on the Heisman Trophy ceremony — which is thought to be given to the most effective participant in faculty soccer — he is torn for a purpose.  

That is as a result of he is good at quarterback. He is thought-about by some to be the most effective highschool soccer participant in Texas historical past. He had a season on the extent of Baker Mayfield, the earlier Heisman winner and a No. 1 choose who has energized Cleveland. And I am not shopping for the can’t-play-in-the-NFL narrative. C.J. Beathard, Cody Kessler and 39-year-old Josh McCown had greater than 100 passing makes an attempt within the league this 12 months. NFL scouts are having a tough time placing a draft grade on Murray as a result of he is a particular expertise we’re not used to seeing. You recognize who else was like that? Russell Wilson.  

He was 5-11, performed some minor league baseball and was doubted so onerous that he slipped to the third spherical earlier than being drafted by the Seahawks. I feel he made the appropriate resolution.  

I am guessing you are going to come again and begin speaking about cash.  

Fagan: I am really not going to make the cash argument. I’ve seen the asinine quantities of cash Sam Bradford has made for being eternally overpaid in that league. And IF Murray’s inventory stays excessive and IF a workforce falls in love with him — obsessions are identified to be fairly frequent amongst NFL decision-makers, for higher or worse — and IF he is taken within the first spherical (particularly early) and IF he stays wholesome for the lifetime of his rookie contract, his incomes potential over the following a number of years is definitely a lot increased in soccer.  

Then again, if he sticks with baseball, he is assured each single a kind of $4.66 million {dollars}. That is cash in hand, and it is a dangerous proposition to show down/give again that signing bonus (both all or a part of it, relying on the precise language in his contract). However I am not somebody who’s going to evangelise in opposition to betting on your self if that is what you’ve got spent your life doing, as Kyler has.   

I really like what Kyler Murray will be as a baseball star. That velocity he reveals on the soccer area will drive opposing groups loopy on the bottom paths and produce highlight-reel catches within the outfield. His enchancment in his second season on the OU baseball workforce was spectacular. His work within the Cape Cod League — the summer time wood-bat league the place faculty gamers go to hone their abilities in preparation for changing into an expert — was legit. He’ll look nice within the A’s kelly-green uniforms, too.  

MORE: NFL Draft order: The full list of picks

Bender: He would, and this Baseball America article affords a fairly complete breakdown of the comparability of his worth in baseball and soccer. I’d not blame Murray one bit if he put that A’s kelly-green uniform both.  

It is simply that the final man to do this type of factor appeared even higher within the silver-and-black Raiders’ uniform. Bo Jackson remains to be the usual for two-way athletes within the fashionable period, and the cross-promotional “Bo Know” marketing campaign was a once-in-a-generation-thing. Murray is aware of that – and that is why he did that tribute picture within the fall. 

Which results in my subsequent level. The second Murray even makes an attempt a two-sport skilled factor he turns into one of many most marketable athletes in both sport. I do not assume he can each play sports activities — particularly being a quarterback — however so far as endorsements I nonetheless assume there’s more cash to be made, sufficient to cowl that signing bonus, with a soccer profession. If it would not work out in soccer, then he can simply do what one other Heisman Trophy winner did.  

Now batting for the New York Mets, left fielder, Tim Tebow.  

Fagan: You assume Bo appeared higher in silver and black? Actually? Bo Jackson was born to put on the crisp, clear royal blue-and-white jersey of Kansas Metropolis. And why I am so excited concerning the thought of seeing an athlete like Murray play baseball? It is due to Bo. I bear in mind as a child watching him RUN UP THE OUTFIELD WALL after catching a ball within the outfield and simply being gobsmacked. I did not know that was attainable for anybody apart from Spider-Man. And the factor is, Bo made RUNNING UP THE DAMN OUTFIELD WALL look pedestrian, like he did that type of factor on a regular basis. 

I am not saying Kyler is Bo. No one is Bo. However Kyler is Kyler and that is fairly rattling particular. The timeline to stardom is completely different, for certain, however in the long term Kyler can separate himself from the sector extra as a baseball participant than he can as a soccer participant.  

And also you joke about Tebow, but it surely may/may occur in September.  

Bender: Murray may get drafted, however he ought to nonetheless play minor league baseball this spring to see the place he stands. That would give the two-sport star extra time to guage what he desires to do. Nonetheless, the trail to the NFL is way quicker than the minor league trek to MLB. That is additionally an element. In any case, “the guts desires what it desires, or else it doesn’t care.”  

I had no thought Emily Dickinson stated that till I appeared it up, but it surely completely applies to Murray. By leaving the door open for soccer, it is clear there’s nonetheless a robust curiosity in it. When he figures out what he desires to do, he’ll be excellent at it. I really feel like pushing a deadline right here resembles what occurred to Jackson, who misplaced his closing 12 months of baseball eligibility after having contact with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers then selected baseball out of spite in opposition to Bucs proprietor Hugh Culverhouse. There is not any purpose for Murray to be pressured like that. 

Although, to your level, Jackson stated he would have never played football within the first place if he had it to do over once more. With that thoughts, I am going to provide the ball. The place do you see Murray in 5 years?   

Fagan: Nicely, Bo is aware of.  

5 years from right this moment, Murray will getting ready for his first full 12 months as a starter within the main leagues. He may have already given A’s followers a style of what is to come back, and he’ll use spring coaching to take the teachings he is discovered from the ups and downs of minor league life and his restricted large league expertise and hit the bottom operating — actually — within the Oakland outfield on Opening Day.  

And he might be completely satisfied together with his option to play baseball.  

MORE: NFL playoff schedule: Dates, times, TV schedule

Bender: 5 years from now, Murray might be getting into his fourth season as an NFL quarterback, with two Tremendous Bowl appearances, together with a championship … Oh wait, I’m nonetheless speaking about Wilson. This is the reality: I don’t know whether or not Murray may reduce it as a profitable quarterback within the NFL. However I do know together with his capability to scramble I need to see it occur. Michael Vick wasn’t essentially the most correct passer within the NFL — he didn’t hit greater than 60 p.c till his stint with the Eagles in 2010, however he made performs. Murray struggled at occasions in opposition to Alabama, however he additionally totaled 308 passing yards, 109 speeding yards and three TDs.  

There are sufficient younger 30-something coaches breaking in to the NFL now with faculty ideas, and numerous that stems from the Large 12. Can Kliff Kingsbury coach within the NFL? I don’t know, however I need to see it, too. And if Murray chooses baseball, then I need him to do effectively there, too.  

However with these two-sport skills, you need them to see each so long as attainable earlier than they make that call as soon as and for all.  

I feel we will each agree on that.  

Show More

Leave a Reply

Close