last night, Yuanzhen Shock Due to various wrong reasons, it became popular on Twitter. Which one is it?Well, this is the truth: no one really agrees that the core of the volcanic eruption that erupts next to it is Developer miHoYo’s cash cow. Currently, #BoycottGenshin tags Consists of legitimate complaints about stereotypes, other complaints that don’t require very few asterisks, and a lot of debate about which is which.
Although it is difficult to trace the exact source of the hashtag, it does seem to increase the speed due to the discussion of Hilichurls (one of them). XuanxinThe most common enemy types- A developer video that briefly introduces indigenous dance Used as their reference point.But others suggested that the conversation start Due to rumors that the upcoming in-game content has been delayed.Since the hashtag started, it has been trending many times Use a different name with Pick up the extra bones to pick upIncluding accusations of racial discrimination and color discrimination, involving two playable characters Xin Xin and Kai Ya, as well as minor NPCs vying to follow other child characters.
The scope of the fans’ debate has been widely announced, that is, all dissatisfaction with the legalization of SJW’s standard culture war strategy, and insistence that games (especially based on reality and can affect reality, especially in games that are popular across continents)Completely divorced from reality. As you can imagine, it’s on Twitter and elsewhere (for example, This Yuanzhen Shock Subreddit.
EBut the argument is The minefield itself in the larger #BoycottGenshin minefield. Hilichurl’s discussion is the clearest statement, it’s what it’s saying because it’s still It’s not entirely clear. To be sure, miHoYo showed a video of an indigenous dance in the studio tour video as a reference for its animal humanoid enemies, but this is not good.
“I just want to say that Hilichurls inspired by indigenous people are definitely not good,” said a player who claimed to be an indigenous person. Wrote on Twitter. “People used to laugh at their dances, but people (including me) now find that this situation is really hurtful. This makes us feel that we are being laughed at something that is of great significance to us. miHoYo, our culture is not something you can accept and use. Things. It’s not good, it’s not funny, I’m really disappointed. Many of us are.”
Even in the anti-#BoycottGenshin crowd, some people agreed that miHoYo dropped the ball here.However, others pointed out that Hilichurls are not pure villains (they are Manipulated by another group of villains) And they are very similar to one of Bokoblins Yuanzhen ShockThe most influential is The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild.The former misunderstands why stereotypes are harmful (just because characters who may not be villains have enacted stereotypes, they don’t suddenly get better), while the latter has become a bigger topic, namely the #BoycottGenshin hashtag is just beginning to study :existing “Primitive” humanoid enemies In many action-adventure games and RPGs.
In short, Bokoblins’ animations, skull necklaces and other portraits more subtly evoke local stereotypes (not to mention other stereotypes, such as those around Haitian Fudu), which are integrated into a series of videos Game enemies, these enemies are based on the stereotype of “tribes” to convey the message of lack of civilization or wisdom.Orcs are Their own conversation, But when discussing the orcs, the author NK Jemisin continued to write about fantasy non-human races.
“An orc is a person who can be slaughtered without a conscience or an apology,” Jemisin wrote in a 2013 blog post. “A creature that looks like a human, but it’s not. It’s a bit like a person whose most basic moral considerations like the right to live are not worthwhile. The only way to deal with them is to completely control them, or completely eliminate them.”
This is not strictly Yuanzhen Shock in other words. Whether we are talking about Hilichurls, Bokoblins, or other endless badass racial fantasies, it will always return to the same ugly calculus. in this aspect, Yuanzhen Shock Neither exemption from liability nor exception. This is Trope’s latest ranking and represents a broader systemic issue in the game. In the medium of imaginable infinite worlds, it may be time to get rid of the notion of subhumans. Maybe it’s already here.
#BoycottGenshin’s other arguments (the tricky people are not all supported by people who support the hashtag).On the one hand, the in-game text Does describe a character with a darker complexionYinyan has a “fierce appearance” that can be compared with “one of the little hooligans wandering in the market”, which inspires the “fear” of people who see her and make their children cry. On the other hand, this seems to be more attributable to her clothes-all spikes and punk rock gear-rather than just her skin tone. Another darker-skinned character, Kaeya, is described as “exotic.” However, this may be because he is from a place called Khaenri’ah, rather than Teyvat, the country where the game took place.
still, Player pointed out Compared to the rest of the game, the skins of these two characters are only black May not be a coincidence It was considered terrible, and it attracted accusations of colorism, but it went further Promote discussion About specific regions of Asia Yuanzhen Shock Is drawing inspiration from its current (and upcoming) language environment. This is also very tricky. Some people cited the Asian roots of the game as a reason to shut down the representatives in the game.Many people do with Representatives opposed to other forms seem to have no first-hand experience of the culture and place they are discussing.
The topic of pedophilia is equally confusing. There are two underage characters, Barbara and Flora, Have older male NPC cravings. In the former case, it is a misguided super fan because Barbara is basically a pop star. In multiple missions, the game described it as being in an awkward situation in a completely bad situation. Taking Flora as an example, things are not that simple. Otherwise, an unknown National People’s Congress stated that he would one day “acknowledge my love for Flora on a dandelion boat”, if not because of the addition of This line, it would be very offensive. In the early version of the game, Flora’s character model at the time was an adult female rather than a child. However, miHoYo has been canceling the production line for several months, and although fans have noticed it previously, it still hasn’t.Then the game Rely on telescope Petite, high-pitched female character with a childish appearance and tendencies- There are also tricky (though less discussed) meanings.
Some people on Twitter have described the #BoycottGenshin feature as the sudden irritation caused by the DLC delay, making it inherently ambiguous. Obviously, despite this, many doubts (and others related to security and game business models) are brewing. Yuanzhen Shock‘S fan base for a while. Whether hashtags will bring tangible changes, or like many other well-intentioned campaigns, whether the modern, participation-driven Internet structure is destined to drown out toxicity remains to be seen.