The two Italian marines are accused of killing fishermen off the coast of Kerala.
The Supreme Court on Friday said it would order the closure of criminal proceedings against two Italian Marines accused of killing fishermen off the coast of Kerala only after Italy paid ₹ 10 crore in compensation to the victims’ families.
Earlier in the trial, both the Center and Kerala told a Bench chaired by Indian Supreme Court Chief Justice Sharad A. Bobde that the family had “happily” agreed to compensation. This amount was over and above the amount of ex gratia Italy had previously paid.
“The trial court does not have the authority to close the trial. The trial can only be closed by the Supreme Court, ”said Attorney General Tushar Mehta to the government.
The top court ordered that the Italian Republic must transfer the amount of compensation to an account number to be submitted to it by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. The ministry in turn will deposit the money to the Supreme Court. The top court will immediately disburse the compensation amount to the family. The court has set a trial date for next Friday, when the money must be deposited in the top court.
It was Kerala who raised the point that compensation must be submitted to the Supreme Court before the criminal trial closes.
“We have consulted with the family and they agree [to the compensation and closure of criminal trial in India] … But the money has to be deposited with the Supreme Court before the trial is canceled, ”senior lawyer Jaideep Gupta, from the Kerala government, said.
CJI agreed, saying “we will ask for the amount to be paid at the Supreme Court, only after that [criminal proceedings] will be closed. “
Lawyer Suhail Dutt, for Italy, said his client was “waiting for the MEA to give him the account number … we will transfer the money”.
The Marines, Salvatore Girone and Massimiliano Latorre, detailed on the Italian ship Enrica Lexie when they allegedly shot fishermen who thought they were “pirates” in 2012. The Marines, now in Italy, will face a criminal investigation there.
The top court hearing is based on an application filed by the Center notifying the Supreme Court that it has decided to “accept and abide by” the international court’s decision that the Marines enjoy immunity from prosecution in India. The government says India is bound by an arbitral tribunal ruling established under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS). It said the court’s decision was “final and without appeal.”
The international court’s finding that the Marines have immunity comes seven years after the Supreme Court ordered the Center to “continue investigating and trial Marines” in a decision on January 18, 2013. The highest court has ordered the Center to set up a Special Court to hear the case. Prior to the Supreme Court’s ruling, the Kerala High Court had also found that the Marines did not enjoy immunity.
However, in 2014, the Marines managed to obtain a restraining order under investigation by the National Investigation Agency. A year later, the Supreme Court froze its own proceedings when the case reached the International Court of Law of the Sea. The top court then, in September 2015, has suspended the case until further orders.
SAME Web table – Posted: Apr 3, 2021 | Last Updated: 55 minutes ago
Posted: Apr 3, 2021 | Last Updated: 55 minutes ago
Listen to the story
Here is the news we estimate we will be able to follow today (Saturday): At least 678,165 confirmed coronavirus cases have been reported in the country, while the death toll has reached 14,613. The number of recovered cases has risen to 607,205. Eight parties affiliated with the Pakistan Democratic Movement have agreed to send reason notices to the Pakistan People’s Party and the Awami National Party. At least 16 people’s eyesight was affected during the free eye screening camp at a private hospital camp in Multan. Interior Minister Sheikh Rasheed Ahmed is heading to Gilgit-Baltistan for a two-day visit. Pakistan’s Meteorological Department has issued a heat wave warning for Karachi as hot weather continues to grip the city. The on-site coronavirus registration process for people over 65 is ongoing. Pakistan’s Supreme Court rejected Tehreek-e-Insaf’s petition against the Election Commission’s decision to hold re-elections in the NA-75 constituency. The accountability court in Lahore will continue to hear references to drinking water for the daughter of PML-N president Rabia Imran and son-in-law Ali Imran Yousuf. They have been declared runaway in the case. PML-N leader Rana Sanaullah will appear at the Special Court for Drug Control. PML-N leaders Khawaja Saad Rafique and Khawaja Salman Rafique will appear before accountability for the trial of the Paragon case. Pakistan U19 cricket team training camp at Gaddafi Lahore Stadium was held for the second day.
Here are the news that we hope we can follow today (Saturday):
At least 678,165 confirmed coronavirus cases have been reported in the country, while the death toll has reached 14,613. The number of cases recovered has reached 607,205.
Eight parties affiliated with the Pakistan Democratic Movement have agreed to send warning notices to the Pakistan People’s Party and the Awami National Party.
At least 16 people’s eyesight was affected during the free eye screening camp at a private hospital in Multan.
Interior Minister Sheikh Rasheed Ahmed is heading to Gilgit-Baltistan for a two-day visit.
Pakistan’s Meteorological Department has issued a heat wave warning for Karachi as hot weather continues to grip the city.
The on-site coronavirus registration process for people over 65 is ongoing.
Pakistan’s Supreme Court rejected Tehreek-e-Insaf’s petition against the Election Commission’s decision to hold re-elections in the NA-75 constituency.
The accountability court in Lahore will continue to hear references to drinking water for the daughter of PML-N president Rabia Imran and son-in-law Ali Imran Yousuf. They have been declared runaway in the case.
PML-N leader Rana Sanaullah will appear at the Special Court for Drug Control.
PML-N Khawaja leaders Saad Rafique and Khawaja Salman Rafique will appear before accountability for the trial of the Paragon case.
The Pakistan U19 cricket team’s training camp at the Gaddafi Lahore Stadium was held for the second day.
heat wave, karachi, heat wave in karachi, PDM split, PDM, Pakistan vs South Africa, Supreme Court, PTI, NA-75 Sialkot,
Islamabad [Pakistan], April 2 (ANI): The PakistanSupreme Court on Friday rejected the ruling government’s appeal against the General Election Commission Pakistan (ECP) direction for re-voting in its entirety NA-75 board constituency. Three judges Supreme Court The judge chaired by Judge Umar Ata Bandial has filed an appeal by Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) candidate Ali Asjad Malhi challenged ECPFeb. 25 orders to be re-elected across constituencies, reports Dawn. In the order, Judge Bandial said the court had made decisions based on the law, the Constitution and its own jurisdiction while saying that guidelines would be issued to prevent such incidents. Malhi then told the media that PTI will think about filing a review petition once the detailed decision has been issued. “We believe we can beat PML-N (Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz). “ React to the news, PML-N Vice President Maryam Nawaz took to Twitter to say that once again proved the Prime Minister Imran Khan and his “fake” government has tried to rob the people of Daska.
Re-election won’t be enough. This robber must answer for stealing people’s votes and kidnapping ECP staff, “he tweeted as he congratulated party workers who opposed the ‘vote theft’. During the Friday trial, ECPLawyer Mian Abdul Rauf argued that the commission’s instructions made no mention of “organized conspiracy” and were based on breaking the law, while PTI Lawyer Shehzad Shaukat is calling for punishment for all those responsible for the disappearance of the chief officer, reports Dawn. The NA-75 by-election, held in early February, was marred by violence after clashes between voters and police broke out in several places, including polling stations and police stations several times during the day. At least two people were killed and three others injured in the shooting incident at the polling station. One of the victims reportedly was a member of the Prime Minister Imran Khan‘s PTI while others belong PML-N. That ECP has ordered re-election on February 25 on March 18 after suspicions that the poll results were faked. The commission also ordered the suspension of several senior police officers including the police commissioner of Sialkot. The commission then changed the date of re-election from March 18 to April 10 after the Punjab government sought time to fill vacant administrative positions, Dawn reported. One of the main accusations related to the Daska by-election has been leveled by PML-N In the ruling party, there were 20 chief officers who “disappeared” with ballot boxes during the polls, reports The News International. (ANI)
Investigations into the allegations, he added, were not mentioned in the commission’s terms of reference, and the government could have them investigated independently.
It also states that no government department cooperates with the commission, except for the National Accountability Bureau (NAB). “The commission chairman did not question Tariq Fawad or Moussavi.”
“The Broadsheet East Restoration Agreement is also evidence of the government’s lack of knowledge regarding international law,” the report said.
The report also includes a note from Judge Saeed which states, “While writing the report at Margalla, I could feel the presence of the wolves,” adding that “their howling cannot stop me from carrying out my duties”
On March 22, the one-person commission consisting of completing its investigation into payments made to the company, reveal that the record of a transfer of $ 1.5 million paid “inadvertently” to a company in 2008 is missing.
According to him, the commission’s 500-page report and relevant notes reveal who made the agreement with the company and under what circumstances.
Thinking the payment was suspicious, the commission called it an act of fraud with the state. It was observed that the files regarding the payment had disappeared from the finance and law ministries as well as from the prosecutor’s office.
Moreover, documentation on Pakistan The High Commission in London linked to the case was also found missing, the commission found.
Broadsheet LLC was set up on the Isle of Man to help the then-then-founded government of Pervez Musharraf and NAB track foreign assets bought by Pakistanis allegedly through their illicit wealth.
This time five years ago, a giant inflatable duck towering over the streets and squares of Brazil’s largest city. Round and yellow, the large tub toy and the accompanying slogan “No more paying ducks” – roughly, No more holding a bag – became a symbol and tagline for the business community fed up with government incompetence, public perversion and rent-hunting. politicians (some of whom, indeed, are in the pockets of the executive). It was an unconventional political statement from a silent class who had done enough politics as usual. Six months and a tsunami of street protests later, President Dilma Rousseff leaves, charged with creative accounting, paving the way for Jair Bolsonaro to growl from the outside.
Will the rubber duck be back? Complicated.
Yes, Bolsonaro stumbled, the national mood took a turn for the worse and the state-owned classes once again sided with misgovernment and its accompanying tragedy. Last weekend, 500 of them signed Open Letter calls for drastic action to stop the Covid-19 pandemic amid a ferocious second wave that has rocked the economy and pushed the public health system to collapse. As of March 23, Brazil recorded 3,158 deaths from SARS-CoV-2, nearly a third of the global pandemic deaths over the previous 24 hours. While the yellow duck has not returned, the public alarm has sounded eleven. Therefore A 16-city symphony of pot blows accompanying Bolsonaro’s national broadcast on Tuesday.
Don’t look into the boardroom to lead the Brazilian termidor. In a country where capitalism engenders ambivalence or worse, top executives know they are risking a backlash by speaking up. However late it was, it was better for them to do it than not. “Democracy is strengthened when all sectors of society have a political voice,” said political scientist Felipe Nunes, who runs the polling company Quaest. “For too long, the business class has played a secondary role, only funding politics, often from the shadows. They need to organize their agenda in plain view. “
State executives, however, are part of the discontent that got Bolsonaro into office in 2019. Few are lured by barks on the stump: Bellicose and impulsive, Bolsonaro is a risk. But most see no other way to dispose of the years of top-down economics and the corruption and cronyism they have engendered. So with the University of Chicago-graduated economics magnate, Paulo Guedes, driving a gun, they put their faith in capitalist harassment. Instead, they end up with quixotic populism and chaos.
The Brazilian economy is projected grew by 3,6% this year, slower than its hemispheric counterparts. Inflation returned, driven by swelling public debt. Even a second dose of emergency cash for the most vulnerable would mean little more than palliative care unless the outbreak can be contained. But a very slow vaccine rollout – Brazil ranks number 60 in doses per 100 population – threatens to exacerbate the world’s steepest pandemic death curve and devastating unpredictable effects for jobs, sales, schools and health care.
“I don’t know if we are at a point of change, but I think the support from the business class has disappeared for a while – due to economic risks, adverse impacts on the quality of democracy, sanitation and environmental risks,” Former Brazilian Central Bank president Arminio Fraga Open Letter signers, tell me.
Bolsonaro’s tough management – cycling through four health ministers within a year, appealed to the Supreme Court against state and local lockdowns, swapped the respected CEO at state oil giant Petrobras for a military man no oil and gas experience – playing poorly in Avenida Brigadeiro Faria Lima, Sao Paulo’s glittering financial lane. “I don’t know anyone in my circle of acquaintances who still identifies himself as a Bolsonarista,” said former finance minister Mailson da Nobrega, a partner at consultancy Tendencias Sao Paulo who also signed the Open Letter. Everyone is disappointed. But not all white collars cause scuffs.
Sergio Lazzarini, a corporate culture scholar at the Sao Paulo Insper business school, divided Bolsonaro’s private sector support into three broad groups: fanatical loyalists, secretly uncomfortable, and those who opposed liberals who were increasingly shocked by palace provocateurs. What keeps many executives in line, Lazzarini argues, is the official temptation paper (tax breaks, concessional loans, subsidies) that Brazilian crony capitalism hangs in the presence of a favored clientele. The group to watch out for is the middle group, whose dangers of attachment begin to outweigh the benefits. “The Brazilian business class has long followed a strategic adaptation strategy,” said Lazzarini. “They don’t lead, but take care of their own interests and change with the wind.”
A shift may be in progress. The public whip over the deepening health emergency has prompted an angry governor and even reliable lawmakers to sharply criticize Bolsonaro, who sounded almost apologetic. speak told reporters on Wednesday. However, more than Bolsonaro’s reluctance was at play. That the executive elite is tense, like the country’s leading left political icon, Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, being reborn as a public figure is no coincidence. The rise of Lula owes its jurisprudential acrobatics in the country’s highest court: In early March, a Supreme Court judges vacate the corruption sentence against the leader of the Workers’ Party (on the grounds that he was tried by the wrong court), thus releasing him from running. Then, on March 23, a panel of five high court judges removed the headlines of corruption and money laundering allegations on Lula’s rap sheet on the grounds that her trial was tainted by the court. an impartial lower court judge, effectively blasting the heart of Carwash’s seven-year investigation into political corruption in Brazil.
More than just a slap to a groping leader, the accusations from the business class are a warning about Brazil’s dangers returning to a crippling zero sum game between two rival brands of populism. “The message from the executives is that if nothing is done to stop the chaos that exists, Brazil risks returning to a polarizing stalemate and leaving the country on a plate to the Labor Party,” said Paulo Bilyk, chief executive of Rio Bravo, an asset manager.
The vibe from the corner office is hard to miss: A country that relies on choleric politics is bad for business, bad for politeness, and ultimately bad for Brazil. If the maestros were successful, neither Bolsonaro nor Lula would win. “They want a third way,” said Nunes. “But in a society driven by WhatsApp and Twitter, it’s hard to imagine a thriving political center.” The Brazilians apparently agreed. Neither of the more than hourly political centric headlines one digit in preference for next year’s presidential election. Just when the country’s business class has found its voice, the suit may be left to speak for itself.
This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.